This article explains the legal distinction between court-approved financial settlements and informal or negotiated financial agreements, including the risks of non-binding arrangements.
Certainty is a common theme separating couples usually want to achieve when deciding the split of their matrimonial finances. Whether you reach an agreement between the two of you, or with the help of solicitors, or using the court process, the best way to achieve certainty is to encapsulate the details of your agreement into a Court Order which is approved by a judge.
A Court Order is a legally enforceable document which sets out the terms of your agreement and is ratified by the court. If the other person breaches the Court Order or goes back on the terms, there are enforcement mechanisms available which enable you to hold them to it.
Every family and relationship is unique and one size does not fit all. There are various ways you can approach splitting your finances on divorce and the law can be complex and nuanced. This can led some into the trap of thinking that they have tied everything up, when the reality is they have not.
A Financial Settlement and a Financial Agreement may sound surprisingly similar in theory, but legally speaking they mean very different things in practice.
Financial Settlement
A Financial Settlement is a legally binding arrangement which determines how your matrimonial assets, liabilities and pensions are divided following divorce. It can also include maintenance (support for your ex-spouse) and will often provide for a Clean Break. A Financial Settlement is usually achieved in one of two ways:
By agreement or consent: this means that couples negotiate between themselves, or with the help of a mediator or solicitor, to reach an agreement. Some clients come in for a first meeting with a clear idea of what they what to happen with their finances, others opt for legal guidance to decide what an appropriate settlement should look like for them.
For this to succeed, both parties need to have a genuine willingness to come to an agreement. Once an agreement has been reached, a solicitor will convert the terms into a Consent Order and it is sent to the court for approval. Only at that point does the Financial Settlement now become legal binding.
By court order: if it is not possible to reach an agreement, then either party can make an application to the court to ask the court to exercise its power to decide how to split their finances.
The court will have regard to the principles set out in Section 25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, including the parties needs and financial resources. Often the court is also asked to factor in pre or post marital assets, contributions, inheritance prospects and health concerns, amongst other things.
Above all, the court’s priority is the welfare of any minor children and ensuring that provision is made for their housing and the costs of their upbringing. The court has a broad discretion on what decision to make and it will seek to achieve an outcome which is fair for both parties. The court will make a Final Order setting out the terms of the Financial Settlement and this is legally binding on both parties immediately.
Whichever route above you take, the important advantage of having a formal Consent Order or Final Order in place is that it gives both parties certainty about their financial future.
Financial Agreement
By contrast, a Financial Agreement is an informal agreement made between parties about the division of their finances following separation or divorce which, crucially, has not been approved by the court.
Often clients come to us explaining that they have come to a verbal understanding or created their own written agreement with their ex-spouse and want advice about what to do when the other person rows back from it. This is something couples often do with the good intentions of being practical, saving the costs of using solicitors and avoiding the court process. However frequently there has been not a proper exchange of full and frank financial disclosure which is essential to evaluate what a fair agreement actually is. So you might be agreeing to give up something which you are in fact entitled to, or signing up to an duly harsh outcome.
Sadly, the health warning here is that such Financial Agreements are not automatically legally binding. Whilst it is possible to try to hold the other party to the agreement by making a court application, it can be difficult and costly to persuade a judge to agree and you could ultimately be unsuccessful.
If you simply rely on a Financial Agreement, which is not legally binding, there is a risk that the other party could change their mind and fail to keep to their agreed responsibilities. Alternatively, if there is no legally binding clean break in place, the financial claims between you both remain open indefinitely which means the other party could come back and make a claim against you at any time in the future, if for instance their financial circumstances took a downturn.
The Bottom Line
Before embarking on the complex journey of splitting your matrimonial finances, we would always recommend you seek specialist legal advice from an experienced family solicitor to ensure that you understand the key legal principles and what a fair and binding financial settlement means for you.